Free Case Review Text us

Trial Pro P.A. is proud to advocate for accident victims all over the state of Florida, including from our Central Florida office in Orlando. Our dedicated experienced personal injury attorneys handle a range of legal matters, from employment disputes to auto accidents claims. We can use our knowledge and legal skills to help you not only achieve a favorable outcome but relieve the legal burden on your shoulders as well. Our entire team understands how challenging and confusing litigation can be, which is why we are here for you through every step of the process.

The Trial Pro, P.A. attorneys, carry more than a century of collective legal experience and decades of working together as a team. We have represented hundreds if not thousands of people who have been injured due to car accidents, slip-and-fall, worker's compensation cases, and more. One thing that is clear to us is the essence of partnership. Without it, Trial Pro, P.A. could not be as effective in attaining success for our clients.

What Makes a Driver Negligent in a Florida Accident?

Frequently Asked Questions - What Makes a Driver Negligent in a Florida Accident?
What Makes a Driver Negligent in a Florida Accident?

The legal definition of negligence in Florida is “the failure to use reasonable care, which is the care that a reasonably careful person would use under like circumstances. Negligence is doing something that a reasonably careful person would not do under like circumstances or failing to do something that a reasonably careful person would do under like circumstances”.  In other words, a person’s conduct is evaluated by comparing said person’s actions to the actions of a person engaging in the same activity who is performing said activity in a careful manner.   In addition, a person can be negligent by failing to take action he or she should have taken.

The most common example is a rear end automobile collision.  Because rear end collisions are nearly universally the fault of the rear driver, Florida Law imposes a legal presumption of negligence on all drivers who cause rear end collisions.  Connecting this concept to the definition of automobile negligence, Florida Law recognizes that drivers who cause rear end collisions were not driving in a reasonably careful manner.  In addition, drivers who cause rear end collisions failed to pay adequate attention, which a reasonable careful driver would have done under the same circumstances.   There is a caveat to the rear end presumption of negligence.  If the front vehicle stopped suddenly, with no warning, in a location where the rear driver would not have expected a sudden stop, the presumption of negligence comes into question.  Attorneys call this the “sudden stop” defense.

However, for all automobile crashes other than rear end collisions, the general definitions above are applicable.  In some instances, a driver’s negligence is obvious, such as a vehicle running a red light where a red light camera captures the event on video.  In other instances, there are eye witnesses who attest to the actions of the drivers, and again the negligence becomes apparent.  However, in some crashes, due to conflicting accounts by drivers and witnesses, an accident reconstruction expert is required to analyze all details of the crash, including the speed of all involved vehicles, the physical damage to the vehicles, physical evidence on the roadway, and statements from any drivers or witnesses.  By analyzing all these factors, an accident reconstruction expert can piece together the events and determine which person or people were negligent.

The determination of negligence does not begin and end with identifying a negligent party.  Under Florida Law, the doctrine of comparative negligence is the legal standard.  Comparative negligence is the determination of how negligent a person or multiple people acted in the course of a crash.  For instance, in our rear end collision example, the rear driver is presumed to be 100% negligent.  But what happens in a situation where a driver passes through a red light, but the other driver recognizes this and has an opportunity to take evasive action and either avoid the crash all together or lessen the impact through defensive actions?  A jury considering that type of scenario would be required to determine if both drivers shared responsibility, and if so the jury would be required to apportion a specific percentage of negligence to each party.  In this example, a jury may find the driver who passed through the red light to be 90% negligent and they may simultaneously find the driver with the right of way to be 10% negligent for failing to take reasonable actions to either avoid the crash all together or lessen the impact.  This analysis would use the portion of the negligence definition above that discusses negligence in terms of failing to act in a reasonable manner.

In some states other than Florida, states apply the doctrine of contributory negligence instead of comparative negligence.  In a contributory negligence jurisdiction, if any party is 1% negligent, that party cannot maintain a lawsuit against any other negligent parties.  As you can imagine, following this doctrine can lead to highly unfair results.  That is why states like Florida have steered away from contributory negligence and instead followed comparative negligence, so that any involved driver will be responsible only for the injurie or damages caused by his or her proportional negligence.

Some driving actions rise to a higher level than ordinary negligence, such as when a driver is impaired by alcohol or drugs while operating his or her vehicle, and in the course of operating the vehicle under the influence she causes a crash.  Or when a driver is racing with another vehicle and in the course of this activity, he causes a crash.   Both of these driver actions are decisions the drivers made, and they involve what we call reckless conduct, which is level above negligence.  These actions subject such drivers to criminal prosecution in addition to their liability in civil actions for negligence.  The effect of these types of drivers’ actions can be extremely inflammatory to juries in civil cases, and for that reason, many attorneys representing drivers who are accused of reckless activities will concede their clients were negligent so that a jury will not hear the specific circumstances of how they caused the crash.  Another avenue for trial attorneys is to petition the court to find the driver was negligent as a matter of law based on the fact the person was impaired or participating in dangerous conduct such as racing.

Finally, automobile negligence can manifest itself in the negligent maintenance of a vehicle.  By driving a vehicle on public roads without being reasonably certain the vehicle is mechanically safe, if there is a system failure due to lack of maintenance, and that failure causes a crash, the vehicle owner may be found negligent.  The most common example is operating a vehicle with dangerously low tire tread.  By operating a vehicle with unacceptable tire tread on public roadways, the operator and owner of the vehicle are putting the public at risk should the tire fail on a highway or city street.   This is another example of failing to do something a reasonably careful person would do under like circumstances.  For these reasons, it is critical to regularly service your vehicle including the brakes, tires, seatbelts, and all other vehicle systems that can affect the safety of the vehicle on the public roads.

Free Case Review Text us
Personal Injury Attorneys
Committed to Your Personal & Financial Recovery


Our goal is to make the process as easy as possible for you. You don't even have to come into our office if you cannot travel or adjust your schedule to make it to us. We're more than happy to come to you!

In addition to traveling directly to our clients, the team at Trial Pro, P.A. also pledges to provide clear advice and regular client communication. We know how vital regular contact with our clients is - we never leave you hanging or delay our responses. 

Mobirise
Orlando Personal Injury Attorneys
After experiencing an automobile accident, the last thing you desire is to have an attorney at hand that doesn’t know how to represent you adequately. You want a reputable law firm that will.
Personal Injury Attorneys
Serious Representation
We put our knowledge and legal abilities into action to assist you to attain a positive outcome and ease the legal stress from your shoulders simultaneously. Trial Pro, P.A., holds a reputation for achieving real success for clients. Please leave it to us to fight wisely but aggressively. 
Personal Injury Lawyer
Unmatched Case Results
Experiencing a car accident can be frustrating and scary, but our promises to you are fully authentic. Trial Pro, P.A.'s injury legal attorneys, do not under-deliver. Instead, we do everything in our capabilities to go above and beyond your expectations. 
Car Accident Lawyers
Committed to Our Clients
It would help if you didn't have to beg for a call back from your attorney. It would be best if you didn't have to beg for an update on your case. At Trial Pro, P.A., we don't operate in that manner. We constantly call our clients to give them updates on their claims. If we miss a call, we promise always to return it.
Orlando Car Accident Lawyer
Compassionate In & Out of Court
Our objective is to enable our clients to relax and concentrate on healing, recognizing that the legal professionals at Trial Pro, P.A. holds the knowledge and resources to adequately tackle all the legal and financial specifics associated with their dispute.
Pursuing Client Victories

Based in Florida, Trial Pro, P.A. represents clients across Florida from our offices in Miami, Orlando, Ft. Myers, Naples, Delray Beach, Jacksonville, and Daytona Beach. We are dedicated to fully serving you to every degree. We vow to make the entire process of working with us as easy and as stress-free as possible. Therefore, we are more than happy to meet with you at your home, place of employment, hospital room, or other business that you find more convenient. You are always welcome to come into our office as well.

Free Case Review Text us

 Send Message
* The following info is required
 Our Locations
Trial Pro P.A. is proud to advocate for accident victims all over the state of Florida. Our dedicated, experienced personal injury attorneys handle various legal matters, from employment disputes to auto accidents claims. We can use our knowledge and legal skills to help you not only achieve a favorable outcome but relieve the legal burden on your shoulders as well. Our entire team understands how challenging and confusing litigation can be, which is why we are here for you through every step of the process.

Trial Pro P.A. Orlando Office

  (407) 300-0000

 250 N Orange Ave 14th Floor
Orlando, FL 32801


Trial Pro P.A. Tampa Office

  (813) 522-5444

 1000 N. Ashley Drive, Suite 512
Tampa, FL, 33602


Trial Pro P.A. Naples Office

  (239) 300-0000

 870 111th Ave N #1
Naples, FL 34108


Trial Pro P.A. Fort Myers Office

  (239) 400-5000

 9341 Marketplace Rd
Fort Myers, FL 33912


Trial Pro P.A. Melbourne Office

  (321) 586-2088

 2551 W. Eau Gallie Blvd., Suite 102
Melbourne, FL, 32935

Contact Info
250 N Orange Ave, 14th Floor
Orlando, FL 32801
help@trialpro.com
(407) 300-0000


Our law firm fights aggressively -- always determined to win your case. 

Trial Pro, P.A. Car Accident Attorneys
Trial Pro, P.A.

The information on this website is for general information purposes only. The Information presented at this site should not be construed as formal legal advice nor the formation of an attorney-client relationship. For medical advice and treatment, you should contact a licensed medical professional.